Baltic Regional Gas Market Coordination Group

Baltic Regional Gas Market Coordination Group

Members

Image
Map of Europe

​​​​The Baltic Regional Gas Market Coordination Group is composed of:

 

  • Finland

  • Estonia

  • Latvia

  • Lithuania​

Baltic Regional Gas Market Coordination Group

A brief historic introduction

​The first Regional Gas Market Coordination Group (RGMCG) Action Plan began on 2017 with the implementation of the implicit capacity allocation of the interconnection points between Latvia-Lithuania and Estonia-Latvia. It provided the organized market place where gas could be easily traded cross-border, while at the same time minimising the administrative burden of potentially having third party access (TPA) and balancing agreements between TSOs.

In 2018, the tariff model and inter-TSO compensation (ITC) mechanism for the common Baltic-Finnish market was created, resulting in a stepwise integration approach.

The NRAs of Finland, Estonia and Latvia (FinEstLat) agreed to strengthen their cooperation and creating the FinEstLat market, which became operational on 1 January 2020.

Baltic Regional Gas Market Coordination Group

The FinEstLat system

The FinEstLat single natural gas transmission entry-exit system, also called the 'FinEstLat system', has specific characteristics.

The NRAs have amended the methodologies for calculating the transmission tariffs and approved the tariff scheme, which became applicable as of 1 January 2020. ACER published its analyses of the consultation documents of the EstonianLatvianLithuanian and Finnish ​reference price methodologies.

Two balancing areas are set up in the FinEstLat system, considering the different level of market maturity in the FinEstLat countries: the common Estonian-Latvian balancing zone and the Finnish balancing zone.

The Regional Gas Market Coordination Group (RGMCG) continues working on a four-country market model, including Lithuania into the regional market.​​​​

Following the Roadmap approved in early 2020:

  • In March 2020: the Common Regulations for the Use of Natural Gas Transmission System were amended eliminating the inconsistencies that arose during the first months of operating Estonia-Latvia common balancing zone.
  • In April-August 2020: external analysis was carried out by Artelys to support a four-country entry tariff area and to design and justify an ITC-model for the four countries that is compliant with all the requirements.
  • In May-August 2020: the TSOs jointly conducted an analysis for further integration options and concluded that full market integration should be decided upon only after operational efficiency is significantly improved (internal congestion eliminated), i.e. after 2024 when PCI “Enhancement of Latvia-Lithuania interconnection” is completed.
  • In August 2020: the region started to develop the Solidarity agreement based on the Regulation safeguarding the security of gas supply.
  • In October 2020: a Memorandum of understanding was signed between the four NRAs to facilitate cooperation, coordination and the creation of the Baltic-Finnish market. A Working Group with the four NRAs was also established.
  • ​In December 2020: the regional TSOs scrutinized the benefits of a common system for issuing and trading guarantees of origin for gre​en gases.

Gas Regional Work Plans

Gas Regional Work Plans

Gas Regional Work Plans

Image
acer image

Following the mandate of the European Commission, the gas regions elaborated regional Work Plans. These outline the main projects and activities to be developed at regional level and serve as the main implementation reference. All projects clearly indicate and plan the deliverables, the deadlines, and responsible parties involved. ​
 

The currently adopted Wo​rk Plan of the So​​uth region focuses on:

  • Infrastructure 

  • Market integration

  • Decarbonisation 

The currently adopted Work Plan of the South South East (SEE) region focuses on:

  • 24h supplier switching survey

  • Updates on market integration between Austria and Italy

  • Survey on Network Codes Implementation on Interconnection Points between the SSE's and Energy Community's TSOs

  • Survey​ on Public procurement rules applied at national level by the TSOs of the SSE Member States and Contracting parties and its results, as well as m​​​​​​ain findings​​
     

The North-West region has been inactive since 2014.

Whenever needed, the Agency provides guidance and coordinates the updates of the Work Plans, suggesting an effective and coherent planning.

Gas Regional Initiatives

Gas Regional Initiatives

Bringing market participants together to test solutions and develop best practices

Image
acer image

The Gas Regional Initiatives (GRIs) bring market participants together to test solutions for cross-border issues and to develop pilot projects that can be exported to other regions.

The European internal gas market has been divided in four main regions:​

  • South GRI

  • South South-East GRI

  • North-West (currently inactive)

  • Regional Gas Market Coordination Group​ region (Baltic Region) (informally joined the initiative in 2018)

Gas Regional Initiatives

Different fora for stakeholders' enagagement

The Initiatives have contributed to noticeable developments in different areas such as capacity allocation, infrastructure development and market integration.

Progresses were possible thanks to effective stakeholders' engagement ensured in different fora:

• Regional Coordination Committee (RCC) 

Composed by all NRAs of the region, it coordinates, facilitates and drives forward the regional priority projects. The European Commission and national governments may provide useful input to identify and solve specific issues.

• Implementation Group (IG) 

Includes the relevant infrastructure operators (transmission systems, interconnectors, LNG and storage facilities) and provides a technical framework for implementing effective solutions.

• Stakeholders Group (SG) 

All other key market participants and consumers are brought together in each region to engage in the discussions.

The Regional Initiatives developed regional Work Plans and cross-regional Roadmaps (in cooperation with ENTSOG), in order to promote the implementation of the Network Codes and market integration. ​

Capacity allocation

Capacity allocation

What is capacity allocation?

​​​ACER monitors the effective implementation of the Capacity Allocation Mechanisms Network Code and shares its findings in a dedicated report. ​

Capacity allocation provides mechanisms to obtain capacity products from transmission system operators. It is usually underpinned with a capacity contract between the network user and the network operator. ​​

Image
acer image

Capacity allocation

Why is capacity allocation important?

​Previous capacity allocation methods did not provide equal and transparent access to potential entrants to the capacity markets, hindering competition.

Capacity allocation

What does ACER say?

​Equal and transparent access to transmission capacity in the EU is not a major obstacle anymore. The progressive reduction of the old capacity contracts and their gradual replacement with new ones addressed most of the existing constraints.​​​

↓ See also

Congestion Management

Congestion Management

Image
acer image

ACER monitors the effective implementation of the Congestion Management Procedures Guidelines and shares its findings in specific reports. ACER also reports on an annual basis on the status of Congestion at Interconnection Points. On this occasion ACER also checks the transparency of the data published on the ENTSOG Transparency Platform and provides guidance on possible improvements. ​
 

What is congestion management? 

Contractual congestion occurs when network users cannot obtain the capacity products of their choice because the capacity demand exceeds the offer. It is different from physical congestion, where technical capacity is used to its full extent. Several measures exist to mitigate and prevent contractual congestion.​​
 

Why is congestion management important?

Congestion management procedures address congestions and improve market efficiency. National regulatory authorities and transmission system operators can decide on the application of these measures.
 

What does ACER say?

 

The Agency reports annually on the status of contractual congestion in EU gas markets and how congestion is managed. Based on the​​ monitoring results, national regulatory authorities can decide on the application of congestion management procedures.

Congestion Management

Implementation monitoring reports on congestion management procedures

ACER provides analyses and case studies in yearly reports about the national implementations on congestion management procedures, evaluating their effects at European level.

The Agency published its first Implementation Monitoring Report on Gas Congestion Management Procedures in 2015 and provided an update a year later. The Agency found incomplete implementation and limited application of congestion management in both years and has continued to promote the usage of congestion management instruments ever since. ​​​​​

↓ See also

Monitoring

Monitoring

What's the role of ACER?

ACER monitors the implementation of network codes and the Guidelines adopted by the European Commission. The Agency has developed methodologies to assess their effectiveness on the functioning of the internal gas market: whether they facilitate market integration, non-discrimination, effective competition, and the efficient functioning of the wholesale market.

These reports are publicly available and widely shared to inform the market, academia, and the public at large.​

Monitoring

Why is monitoring important?

Monitoring supports the correct implementation of the regulatory framework and allows to take stock of the progress made and the deficiencies to be addressed. The implementation monitoring is also helpful to clarify the understanding and the application of the EU legal terminology.

Image
acer image

Monitoring

What does ACER say?

​ACER acknowledges the significant progress in harmonising capacity, balancing, interoperability, data exchange and tariff rules across the European Union. 

ACER regrets that a minority of Member States have not completed their legal requirements in full, and encourages those facing pending implementation issues to actively communicate their problems to the Agency and the European Commission. ​

Interconnection agreement

Interconnection agreement

What is it?

Image
acer image

The Interconnection Agreement Template covers the default terms and conditions for the minimum mandatory content of an interconnection agreement, based on the Code's requirements. In case transmission system operators fail to agree on one or more contractual terms, this template can be annexed to the agreement indicating default rules for the disagreed term(s).

An Interconnection agreement is made between adjacent transmission system operators, whose systems are connected at a particular interconnection point. This agreement specifies terms and conditions, operating procedures and provisions with respect to delivery and/or withdrawal of gas at the interconnection point.

Interconnection agreement

Why is there an agreement specific template?

The template covers the mandatory terms for an Interconnection Agreement. It provides ready-made solutions to facilitate the signature of these agreements between transmission system operators if they cannot agree. The mandatory terms of an interconnection agreement cover:

  • rules for flow control

  • measurement principles for gas quantities and quality

  • rules for the matching process

  • rules for the allocation of gas quantities

  • communication procedures in case of exceptional events

  • settlement of disputes arising from interconnection agreements

  • amendment process for the interconnection agreement.

Interconnection agreement

What does ACER say?

Interconnection agreements are mostly signed with a high level of compliance. The Agency recommended that by the end of 2020 national regulatory authorities proactively assess these agreements to further increase compliance and report to the Agency.​​

Common Network Operation Tools

Common Network Operation Tools

What are the CNOTS?

Image
acer image

​​​​Appropriate and secure data exchange facilitates cross-border transmission activities. Common data exchange solutions support the implementation of the gas network codes. ​​​​

The common network operation tools (CNOTs) ensure coordination of network operations in normal and emergency conditions. These tools are developed to facilitate data exchange for capacity allocation and balancing.​

Common Network Operation Tools

What is their use?

​The data exchange table lists the most appropriate data exchange solutions for near real-time communication, the integrated data exchange for real-time communication, and the interactive data exchange for non-time critical communication of TSOs and Booking Platforms.​

Common Network Operation Tools

What does ACER say?

​ACER found ENTSOG's CNOT table compliant with the legislation and recommended ENTSOG a periodical review, as technical processes and needs evolve. In 2017, the Agency opinion on the Adoption of Common Network Operation Tools by ENTSOG was adopted.​

Multiplier Recommendation

Multiplier Recommendation

What is it about?

Image
acer image

Multipliers are factors used to set tariffs for short-term capacity products (within-day, daily, monthly and quarterly). 

​The Network Code on Harmonised Transmission Tariff structures sets obligations for national regulatory authorities (NRAs) to consult on multipliers and defines appropriate ranges for the level of these multipliers.

In parallel with these processes, ACER issued a recommendation on 20 July 2021, encouraging national regulatory authorities to better substantiate their decisions where daily and within-day multipliers are set above 3. In particular, they should base their justifications on the specificities of each interconnection point and make explicit their regulatory objectives (market integration, liquidity, competition, cost reflectivity and tariff stability, etc.).

The Agency also recommends NRAs of those Member States connected by transmission pipelines to better coordinate their decisions when setting multipliers in combination with seasonal factors. ​

Access the Recommendation 01/2021.

Read more on its Annexes I and II (overview of multiplier levels & analysis and evaluation of responses).

Tariff consultation template

Tariff consultation template

What is it?

Image
acer image

The Tariff consultation template facilitates the interactions between ACER and the NRAs or TSOs in the context of the national consultations' review. ACER strongly recommends its usage while carrying out the tariff consultation.

The template explicates the requirements to be fulfilled by the consultations (not intended to constitute additional legal requirements). 

The template allows:

  • checklist of consultation obligations on the Reference Price Methodologies: providing a summary of the final consultation.

  • The submission of consultation documentation to ACER.

  • Publication of consultation summary submitted by the NRAs or TSOs on ACER website containing the appropriate references to the national consultation document(s).

  • Access to these summaries for stakeholders on ACER website.

Tariff consultation template

Editing and submission instructions

The online template can be filled as of its date of publication (5 July 2017). It can be saved as a draft and can be subsequently updated following the steps of the national process until the final submission.

When saving the template as a draft, the tool provides a link which is necessary to continue editing the draft.

Once the online template is submitted, the tool provides a Case ID which allows editing the online tool post submission.