Expert group on wholesale energy market surveillance
Expert group on wholesale energy market surveillance
Scope of the group
This group was active from 2012-2014 with the goal of advising and assisting the Agency and national regulatory authorities in preparing for their wholesale energy market monitoring and surveillance activities. Specifically, the group aimed to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of the market monitoring activities, including the use of various market monitoring and surveillance tools.
Expert group on wholesale energy market surveillance
Members
-
Mr Cosimo Campidoglio, Head of Market Surveillance department at GME, Italy
-
Mr Christian Giswold, Market Surveillance of Nord Pool Spot, Norway
-
Mr Rafael Gómez-Elvira González, Director of the Chairman & CEO's Office at OMIE, Spain
-
Dr. A.J. Kool, Head of Risk & Compliance of APX/Endex, Netherlands
-
Mr Erik Korsvold, Head of Market Surveillance of Nasdaq/OMX, Norway
-
Dr. Wolfgang von Rintelen, Head of Market Surveillance of EEX, Germany
-
Ms Andrea Stejskalova, Market Surveillance Expert at OTE, Czech Republic
-
Dr. Matjas Vajta, Head of Market Surveillance of HUPX, Hungary
-
Ms Florence Vary, Head of Market Surveillance of EPEX Spot, France
Documents
Expert group on REMIT implementation measures
Expert group on REMIT implementation measures
Scope of the group
This group was active from 2012-2013 with the goal of providing expert support to the Agency during the development of guidance, recommendations and transparency rules in the implementation phase of the REMIT Regulation.
Expert group on REMIT implementation measures
Members
-
Mr Amrik Bal, Shell Energy Europe Ltd, Regulatory Affairs Team, UK
-
Ms Camilla Berg, Nord Pool Spot, Head of Legal Department & Market Surveillance, Norway
-
Mr Mark Dalton, BG Group, European Regulation Manager, UK
-
Mr Michel Gadaleta, JP Morgan, Executive Director, UK
-
Dr. Karl-Peter Horstmann, RWE Supply & Trading, Head of Fundamental Legal & Regulatory Affairs, Germany
-
Ms Daniela Nigro, Endesa SA, International Regulation, Spain
-
Ms Marie-Louise Piil Christensen, DONG Energy, Compliance Officer, Denmark
-
Mr Fabrizio Rinaldi, Edison Trading SpA, Director of Market Strategy & Derivatives, Italy
-
Mr Jean-Michel Salagnac, EDF, Deputy Head of the Optimization Center, France
-
Mr Barry Shackleton, ExxonMobil Gas & Power Marketing, European Regulatory Associate, UK
-
Mr Alain Taccoen, RTE, Deputy Head of Regulation, France
-
Mr Daniel Wragge, European Energy Exchange (EEX), Head Political Communication, Germany
Minutes
Ad hoc expert group on REMIT
Ad hoc expert group on REMIT
Scope of the group
This group was active from 2015-2017 with the goal of advising the Agency on issues relating to market participants' compliance with REMIT. The group was particularly focused on the disclosure of inside information, market abuse prohibitions, registration and transaction reporting obligations.
Ad hoc expert group on REMIT
Members & Observers
-
Ms Camilla Berg
-
Mr Karl-Peter Horstmann
-
Ms Daniela Nigro
-
Ms Marie-Louise Piil Christensen
-
Mr Jean-Michel Salagnac
-
Mr Filip Sleeuwagen
-
Mr Daniel Smith
-
Ms Sophie Tolley
-
Mr Bernhard Walter
-
Mr Daniel Wragge
-
Ms Christelle Coppens-Chalhoub (as observer for ENTSO-E) and
-
Mr Davide Volzone (as observer for ENTSOG)
Minutes
-
Jointly organised with the AEMPs roundtable
IT expert group for the implementation of REMIT
IT expert group for the implementation of REMIT
Scope of the group
This group was active in 2012 with the goal of providing expert support to the Agency during the REMIT implementation phase on IT-related issues.
IT expert group for the implementation of REMIT
Members
-
Hugh Brunswick, EFETnet
-
Filip Sleeuwagen, EFET
-
Volker Reinhoff, CEDEC
-
Mathias Ponnwitz, EEX
-
Joao Manuel Rebelo da Cruz Morais, OMIP
-
Lars-Johan Furborg, Nasdaq OMX Commodities
-
Daniel Smith, Trayport
-
Mark Earthey, Triple Point Technology
-
Martin Reisner, ENTSOG
-
Dalius Sulga, ENTSO-E
BoR Meetings
Meeting agendas, minutes and other documents
| 2026 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 142nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 141st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 140th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 139th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 138th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 137th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2025 | |||
| 136th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 135th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 134th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 133rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 132nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 131st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 130th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 129th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2024 | |||
| 128th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 127th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 126th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 125th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 124th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 123rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 122nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 121st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2023 | |||
| 120th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 119TH BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 118th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 117th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 116th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 115th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 114th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 113th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2022 | |||
| 112th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 111th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 110th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 109th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 108th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 107th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 106th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 105th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2021 | |||
| 104th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 103rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 102nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 101th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 100th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 99th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 98th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 97th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2020 | |||
| 96th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 95th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 94th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 93rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 92nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 91st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 90th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 89th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 88th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2019 | |||
| 87th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 86th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 85th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 84th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 83rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 82nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 81st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 80th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2018 | |||
| 79th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 78th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 77th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 76th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 75th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 74th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 73rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 72nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2017 | |||
| 71st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 70th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 69th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 68th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 67th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 66th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 65th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 64th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 63rd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2016 | |||
| 62nd BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 61st BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 60th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 59th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 58th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 57th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 56th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 55th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 54th BoR meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
Are you a registered NRA? You can be interested in our:
Board of Regulators
Board of Regulators
Role
The Board of Regulators plays a key role within the Agency. It is in charge of the regulatory policy and provides opinions on various Agency Acts considered for adoption and issues guidance to the Director.
It approves the Agency’s work programme and is consulted on other key matters.
Board of Regulators
Composition and Independence
The Board of Regulators consists of senior representatives of the 27 National Regulatory Authorities (NRAs) of Member States and non-voting representatives from EEA EFTA States, the European Commission and the EFTA Surveillance Authority.
The Board of Regulators must act independently and must not take instructions from any government of a Member State, from the European Commission, or from another public or private entity.
Board of Regulators
Rules of Procedure
The Board of Regulators adopts its rules of procedure, regulating the way NRAs cooperate together through ACER.
Decisions of the BoR are adopted on the basis of a two-thirds majority of the members present (each member has only one vote).
Are you a registered NRA? Check our:
-
Access is granted only to BoR registered members.
Possible Hearings
Schedule of possible hearings
|
Case N. |
Possible date of oral hearing |
Place of oral hearing |
|---|---|---|
| Case A-001-2022 | 16 March 2022 - 3 pm CET | Videoconference |
| Case A-013-2021 |
10 February 2022 - 2 pm CET (postponed hearing) |
Teleconference |
| 25 November 2021 - 9 am CET | Teleconference | |
| Case A-001-2021 (consolidated) | 17 May 2021 - 9 am CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-007-2021 (consolidated) | 17 May 2021 - 14 pm CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-011-2021 (consolidated) | 17 May 2021 - 16:30 pm CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-008-2020 | 10 November 2020 - 9:30am CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-007-2020 | 2 September 2020 - 9:30am CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-003-2020 (consolidated) |
18 June 2020 - 2pm CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-002-2020 (consolidated) |
18 June 2020 - 11am CET | Teleconference |
| Case A-001-2020 (consolidated) |
18 June 2020 - 9am CET | Teleconference |
|
Case N.: A-006-2019 |
9 January 2020 |
Brussels, CEER premises |
|
Case A-004-2019 (consolidated) |
25 July 2019 - 10 am CET |
Teleconference* |
|
Case A-003-2019 BNetzA/ACER |
11 June 2019 |
-- |
|
Case A-002-2019 TransnetBW GmbH/ACER |
11 June 2019 |
-- |
|
Case A-001-2019 Amprion GmbH/ACER
|
11 June 2019 |
-- |
|
12 February 2019 - 10.30 to 13.30 CET |
Teleconference |
|
|
26 September 2018 to 3 October 2018 |
ACER Premises |
|
|
28 February 2017 to 3 March 2017 |
ACER Premises - Ljubljana |
|
|
28 February 2017 to 3 March 2017 |
ACER Premises - Ljubljana |
|
|
28 February 2017 to 3 March 2017 |
ACER Premises - Ljubljana |
|
|
28 February 2017 to 3 March 2017 |
ACER Premises - Ljubljana |
*For further information please contact:
BoA(at)acer.europa.eu
↓ See Also
Procedural Documents
Procedural Documents
Procedural Documents and useful Instructions
ACER Board of Appeal adopted the Rules of Organisation and Procedure for appeals in 2019. These Rules (last amended in November 2023) establish the framework for the appeal process, ensuring efficient decision-making and upholding the procedural rights of the parties involved.
To support parties acting in compliance with the legal requirements and prepare their appeals in the most effective way, the Board of Appeal has adopted Practice Directions and a set of templates (cover sheet with general information, table of annexes, confidentiality request, announcement of appeal and a checklist).
Whilst they are not compulsory, the Board recommends their use to avoid possible delays or declarations of inadmissibility.
The Board of Appeal has also adopted Instructions to the Registrar which can be found in the box below.
The relationship of the Board of Appeal and the Agency in administrative terms is governed by the Administrative Arrangement.
BoA Meetings
Agendas, Minutes of meetings and other documents
| 2026 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 28th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2025 | |||
| 27th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2024 | |||
| 26th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2023 | |||
| 25th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2022 | |||
| 24th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2021 | |||
| 1st Extraordinary General Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2020 | |||
| 23rd BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 22nd BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 21st BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 20th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 19th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 18th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2019 | |||
| 17th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 16th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 15th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2018 | |||
| 14th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 13th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 12th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2017 | |||
| 11th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 10th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 9th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 8th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2016 | |||
| 7th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 6th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2015 | |||
| 5th BoA Meeting (restricted) | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 4th BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2014 | |||
| 3rd BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2013 | |||
| 2nd BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
| 2011 | |||
| 1st BoA Meeting | Agenda | Minutes | Background documents |
Board of Appeal
Board of Appeal
Role
The ACER Regulation grants ACER the authority to make individual decisions and establishes a Board of Appeal to handle appeals against specific decisions, outlined in Article 2(d). These include decisions related to:
- requests for information;
- approval of methodologies;
- terms and conditions;
- infrastructure; and
- some aspects of wholesale market integrity and transparency.
Any natural or legal person may appeal an ACER decision that is addressed to them or is of direct and individual concern to them.
The Board of Appeal operates as an independent body to address complaints lodged against ACER decisions. It examines whether the appeal is valid and can either confirm ACER’s decision or remit the case back to the competent ACER body for further action.
Decisions taken by the Board of Appeal may as well be appealed before the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Board of Appeal
Composition and Independence
The Board of Appeal is part of ACER but at the same time independent from its administrative and regulatory structure. It is essential that members and alternates act independently and in the public interest.
The Board of Appeal is composed by six members and six alternates for a mandate of 5 years (renewable once).
Members and alternates are selected among current or former senior staff of the national regulatory authorities (NRAs), competition authorities or other national or EU institutions with relevant experience in the energy sector.
The Board designates its Chair and Vice-Chair from among its members. The Chair is responsible for presiding and allocating appeal proceedings, while the Vice-Chair steps in for the Chair in case of unavailability.
Board of Appeal
Registry of the Board of Appeal
To ensure the Board of Appeal operates smoothly and efficiently, a Registry has been established. The Registry supports the Board by managing the appeal process, handling correspondence and maintaining case files.
For more information on the Registry’s responsibilities, please refer to the Instructions to the Registrar.
For questions on the appeal procedure, you can contact the Registry via email at:
European Union Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators
Trg republike 3
1000 Ljubljana
Slovenia